Why does Claude make up leads?
Claude makes up leads because it has no lead database: asked for companies from memory, it writes names that fit the pattern, with sizes and websites from old training data, and it can't check them.
superagnt is a marketing plugin for Claude and ChatGPT that helps businesses find customers through outbound, SEO and ads. Connected, Claude pulls real company and people rows, each with its LinkedIn page or website, and only ranks and writes. We asked Claude for 25 companies from memory and checked every one: 4 fit the ask, and 3 of the websites were wrong.
Connect superagnt to Claude
Copy the setup prompt.
Your agent does the rest.
Install superagnt for me. It's the superagnt plugin from the github.com/superagnt/plugins marketplace, plus the superagnt MCP server (on Claude it's a connector I add in my browser; elsewhere I sign in through my browser). The setup guide for each kind of agent is at https://www.superagnt.com/install» the base connection serves company search, company records, people search and email finding. Nothing to switch on.
What Claude does alone, and what changes once it's connected
| job | Claude on its own | with superagnt |
|---|---|---|
| Build a list | Writes names from memory, with no way to check that each company exists or still fits. | data_linkedin_search and data_agnt_companies return real companies, each with its LinkedIn page and website. |
| Size, HQ and industry | From training data, which can be years old. | bulk_enrich fills headcount, HQ and industry for up to 100 companies in one call. A company with no record costs nothing. |
| Decision makers | Guesses names and titles, or declines. | data_agnt_people searches by company and seniority and returns each person's title, LinkedIn profile and email status. |
| Show its sources | Can't cite a source for a name it wrote itself. | Every row carries a link you can open, so Claude can show where it came from. |
The job, run on superagnt
Real tool calls on superagnt's staging environment, the same calls Claude makes once the server is connected. Each result is what the client received, trimmed where it says so and otherwise unchanged, and each wall time was measured around the call.
“I'm building a list for cold outreach. List 25 US companies that fit my ICP: B2B software companies with 11 to 50 employees that sell to HVAC, plumbing or electrical contractors. Give each company's name and website, one per line.”
- 01Search companies that fit the ICP1.6 s wall time0.9¢→ call
data_linkedin_search{ "action": "companies", "keyword": "field service software HVAC plumbing", "companySizes": [ "C" ], "locations": [ 103644278 ] }← result| name | username | tagline | url | | --- | --- | --- | --- | | Field Promax \| Field Service Management Software | field-promax | Mobile Integrated Field Service Management Software | https://www.linkedin.com/company/field-promax/ | | Field Complete | fieldcomplete | FieldComplete is building the next generation of field service software from the inside out. Developed by a team... | https://www.linkedin.com/company/fieldcomplete/ | | Sera Systems | serasystems | Sera Systems is an innovative field service management (FSM) platform built to help HVAC, plumbing, and electrical... | https://www.linkedin.com/company/serasystems/ | | Asymmetric Marketing LLC | asymmetricmarketing | ...plumbing, HVAC, roofing, and restoration shops at record paces… | https://www.linkedin.com/company/asymmetricmarketing/ | | City Ranked | city-ranked | ...management as one connected system for home service businesses, including HVAC, plumbing, pest control, landscaping... | https://www.linkedin.com/company/city-ranked/ | | MobiWork LLC | mobiwork-llc | MobiWork is a Field Services Management (FSM) software solution that helps businesses with field employees... | https://www.linkedin.com/company/mobiwork-llc/ | | Aptora | aptora-corporation | Total Quickbooks Replacement Software Made by Contractors, for Contractors • Specialties: Field Service Software | https://www.linkedin.com/company/aptora-corporation/ | | Ascora Field Service Management | ascorajobmangement | Field Service Management (FSM) for Mid-Sized Contractors \| HVAC, Plumbing, Electrical, Fire, and Construction | https://www.linkedin.com/company/ascorajobmangement/ | | Easy Field Services | easyfieldservices | Amidst the ever-evolving landscape of the field service sector, Easy Field Services Field Service Management Software... | https://www.linkedin.com/company/easyfieldservices/ | | Ventus Software | ventussoftware | Enterprise Software Built for Specialty Contractors • Specialties: Field Service Software | https://www.linkedin.com/company/ventussoftware/ | 10 of 20 companies · cost 0.9¢» Trimmed: the end of one tagline, at the …
- 02Pull each company's record: website, size, industry10.4 s wall time17.82¢→ call
data_agnt_companies{ "action": "bulk_enrich", "inputs": [ { "identifier": "field-promax", "linkedin_url": "https://www.linkedin.com/company/field-promax/" }, { "identifier": "fieldcomplete", "linkedin_url": "https://www.linkedin.com/company/fieldcomplete/" }, { "identifier": "serasystems", "linkedin_url": "https://www.linkedin.com/company/serasystems/" }, { "identifier": "asymmetricmarketing", "linkedin_url": "https://www.linkedin.com/company/asymmetricmarketing/" }, { "identifier": "city-ranked", "linkedin_url": "https://www.linkedin.com/company/city-ranked/" }, { "identifier": "mobiwork-llc", "linkedin_url": "https://www.linkedin.com/company/mobiwork-llc/" }, { "identifier": "aptora-corporation", "linkedin_url": "https://www.linkedin.com/company/aptora-corporation/" }, { "identifier": "ascorajobmangement", "linkedin_url": "https://www.linkedin.com/company/ascorajobmangement/" }, { "identifier": "easyfieldservices", "linkedin_url": "https://www.linkedin.com/company/easyfieldservices/" }, { "identifier": "ventussoftware", "linkedin_url": "https://www.linkedin.com/company/ventussoftware/" } ], "fields": ["name", "domain", "employee_count", "industry", "hq_location"], "max_cost_cents_per_record": 1.98 }← result| identifier | name | domain | industry | employee_count | hq_location | funding_total | linkedin_url | | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | | field-promax | Field Promax \| Field Service Management Software | fieldpromax.com | Software Development | 11 | Rochester, Minnesota, United States | | https://www.linkedin.com/company/field-promax | | fieldcomplete | Field Complete | fieldcomplete.com | Software Development | 14 | Atlanta, Georgia, United States | $1.9M | https://www.linkedin.com/company/fieldcomplete | | serasystems | Sera Systems | sera.tech | Software Development | 31 | Grapevine, Texas, United States | | https://www.linkedin.com/company/serasystems | | asymmetricmarketing | Asymmetric Marketing | asymmetric.pro | Marketing Services | 13 | Madison, Wisconsin, United States | | https://www.linkedin.com/company/asymmetricmarketing | | city-ranked | City Ranked | cityranked.com | Advertising Services | 29 | Vancouver, Washington, United States | | https://www.linkedin.com/company/city-ranked | | mobiwork-llc | MobiWork | mobiwork.com | Software Development | 30 | Boca Raton, Florida, United States | $1.5M | https://www.linkedin.com/company/mobiwork-llc | | aptora-corporation | Aptora | aptora.com | Software Development | 21 | Lenexa, Kansas, United States | | https://www.linkedin.com/company/aptora-corporation | | ascorajobmangement | Ascora Field Service Management | ascora.com.au | Software Development | 9 | Austin, Texas, United States | | https://www.linkedin.com/company/ascorajobmangement | | easyfieldservices | Easy Field Services | | Software Development | 1 | Dallas, Texas, United States | | https://www.linkedin.com/company/easyfieldservices | | ventussoftware | Ventus Software | vertical-market.com | Software Development | 8 | Pensacola, Florida, United States | | https://www.linkedin.com/company/ventussoftware | 10 companies · cost 17.82¢ - 03Find the decision makers at the five that fit738 ms wall time1.98¢→ call
data_agnt_people{ "action": "search", "filters": { "company": { "websites": { "include": ["fieldpromax.com", "fieldcomplete.com", "sera.tech", "mobiwork.com", "aptora.com"] } }, "person_seniority": { "include": ["Founder/Owner", "C-Suite", "Vice President", "Head"] } } }← result| job_title | seniority | company_name | company_domain | country | email_status | | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | | Founder | Founder/Owner | Field Promax \| Field Service Management Software | fieldpromax.com | United States | VERIFIED | | Chief Revenue Officer | C-Suite | Sera Systems | sera.tech | United States | VERIFIED | | Vice President of Customer Success | Vice President | Sera Systems | sera.tech | United States | VERIFIED | | Chief Executive Officer | C-Suite | Sera Systems | sera.tech | United States | VERIFIED | | Head of Product | Head | Field Complete | fieldcomplete.com | United States | VERIFIED | | VP of Customer Success | Vice President | MobiWork | mobiwork.com | United States | VERIFIED | | CTO & Co-Founder | C-Suite | Field Complete | fieldcomplete.com | United States | UNAVAILABLE | | Product & User Development \| Co-Founder | Founder/Owner | Field Complete | fieldcomplete.com | United States | VERIFIED | | VP of Software Engineering | Vice President | Sera Systems | sera.tech | United States | UNAVAILABLE | | Vice President of Sales | Vice President | Sera Systems | sera.tech | United States | UNAVAILABLE | | ceo | C-Suite | MobiWork | mobiwork.com | Hong Kong | UNAVAILABLE | 11 of 11 people · cost 1.98¢» Trimmed: the full_name and linkedin_url columns: every row has both.
Three calls, 20.7¢. Every company came back with its LinkedIn page, and Claude kept the five that are US software companies with 11 to 50 people: Field Promax, FieldComplete, Sera Systems, MobiWork and Aptora. It dropped two marketing agencies and three with fewer than 11 people, and nothing on the list came from its memory. The people search then found eleven leaders at the five, each with a profile link to check.
Set it up in your client
Claude
- 01Open the prefilled Add custom connector dialog on claude.ai. One connector covers Claude on the web, Claude Desktop and Cowork.
- 02Click Add, then approve on the superagnt consent screen. It creates your superagnt account if you don't have one.
- 03Ask: “Build my lead list only from what your tools return: no company that isn't in a tool result. <describe your ICP>”
Free plans can add one custom connector. On Team and Enterprise plans, an owner adds it under Organization settings, Connectors (Anthropic).
Claude Code
- 01In Claude Code, run
/plugin marketplace add superagnt/plugins, then/plugin install superagnt@superagntfor the superagnt skills. - 02Add superagnt to Claude as a connector with the prefilled dialog and click Add. Claude Code signed in with your Claude account picks it up.
- 03Start a new session.
- 04Ask: “Build my lead list only from what your tools return: no company that isn't in a tool result. <describe your ICP>”
ChatGPT
- 01In ChatGPT on the web, go to Plugins, select the plus button, then Add custom MCP server.
- 02Name it superagnt, enter the server URL under Connection, and set Authentication to OAuth. The server URL is
https://mcp.superagnt.com/mcp. - 03Tick "I understand and want to continue", then select Create as a plugin. Sign in to superagnt when asked. No token needed.
- 04Install the plugin, then start a new chat, type @ and select superagnt.
- 05Ask: “Build my lead list only from what your tools return: no company that isn't in a tool result. <describe your ICP>”
ChatGPT takes custom MCP servers on the web, not on mobile. Business and Enterprise/Edu workspaces get every tool; Pro accounts get read and fetch actions, which is all this job needs (OpenAI).
Codex
- 01In a terminal, run
codex mcp add superagnt --url https://mcp.superagnt.com/mcp, thencodex mcp login superagnt. The login opens a browser to approve. - 02Start a new Codex session.
- 03Ask: “Build my lead list only from what your tools return: no company that isn't in a tool result. <describe your ICP>”
We asked Claude for 25 leads from memory, then checked every one: 4 fit
Same ask as the run above, on Nov 18, 2026, to Claude (claude-sonnet-5) running as a superagnt hosted agent with no tools and web search off: the session logged 0 web searches and 0 fetches. It answered in 70 seconds with 25 companies and this note:
I don't have a live data/search tool in this session, so this list is built from general knowledge of the field-service-software space, not a verified real-time pull.| Company, as Claude wrote it | Website it gave | What the check found | Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|
| ServiceTrade | servicetrade.com | Site up. 234 people, Durham, NC | Wrong size |
| Aptora (Total Office Manager) | aptora.com | Site up. 21 people, Lenexa, KS, contractor software | Fits |
| Smart Service (My Service Depot) | smartservice.com | Site up. The record matched a different company | Not confirmed |
| Briostack | briostack.com | Site up. 21 people, pest control and lawn care software | Other market |
| GorillaDesk | gorilladesk.com | Site up. 10 people, pest control software | Other market |
| Call of Service | callofservice.com | The domain doesn't resolve, and no record exists | Wrong website |
| Markate | markate.com | Site up. 42 people, Scottsdale, AZ, field service software | Fits |
| Sera | getsera.com | A parked domain. Sera's real site is sera.tech | Wrong website |
| RazorSync | razorsync.com | Site up. 10 people, Brentwood, TN | Wrong size |
| Zuper | zuperinc.com | Redirects to zuper.co. No record under the domain given | Not confirmed |
| FieldPulse | fieldpulse.com | Site up. 218 people, Dallas, TX | Wrong size |
| Kickserv | kickserv.com | Site up. 6 people, Denver, CO | Wrong size |
| Service Fusion | servicefusion.com | Site up. 53 people, Irving, TX | Wrong size |
| Dispatch | dispatch.me | Site up. 200 people, Boston, MA | Wrong size |
| Fieldpoint | fieldpoint.net | Site up. 35 people, Oakville, Ontario | Not in the US |
| ThermoGRID | thermogrid.com | Redirects to another company's site. No record | Wrong website |
| Successware | successware.com | Site up. 33 people, Jessup, MD, HVAC, plumbing and electrical software | Fits |
| Workiz | workiz.com | Site up. 157 people, San Diego, CA | Wrong size |
| mHelpDesk | mhelpdesk.com | Site up. 18 people, Fairfax, VA, field service software | Fits |
| FieldEdge | fieldedge.com | Site up. 139 people | Wrong size |
| Service Direct | servicedirect.com | Site up. 59 people, a pay-per-call lead marketplace, not software | Other market |
| ServMan | servman.com | Site up. The record matched a UK reseller | Not confirmed |
| ServiceBridge | servicebridge.com | Site up. 1 person on its record | Wrong size |
| FieldConnect | fieldconnect.com | Site up. 10 people, Raleigh, NC | Wrong size |
| BuildOps | buildops.com | Site up. 630 people, Santa Monica, CA | Wrong size |
Each website was opened from a server on Nov 18, 2026. Size, HQ and industry are from superagnt's company records: one bulk_enrich call for the 21 companies that matched.
- 4 of 25 fit: US software for contractors, with 11 to 50 people.
- 11 were the wrong size, from 1 person to 630.
- 3 sell to other markets: two to pest control, one is a lead marketplace, not software.
- 3 websites were wrong: one domain doesn't resolve, one is parked, one now redirects to another company.
- 1 is in Canada, and 3 couldn't be confirmed under the website Claude gave.
Most names were real companies: Claude knows this market. What it can't know is today's headcount, where a company moved its site, or which product line got bought. That's the part a list lives or dies on, and it's the part a data tool returns with a source.
Why Claude and ChatGPT invent companies, and what web search does and doesn't fix
- A model writes the most likely next words. Asked for 25 companies, it writes 25 names that look like the pattern, whether or not it has 25 real ones.
- Its facts stop at its training data. Sizes, owners and websites change after that, and nothing in the chat tells it so.
- It can't check its own output. Without a tool, there's no lookup to fail, so a wrong website reads as confidently as a right one.
- A broad ask makes it worse: "50 companies that fit my ICP" pushes it to fill the count.
- Web search helps it confirm one company at a time, but it returns pages, not rows: no headcount, no decision makers, nothing to sort by. See Can Claude find email addresses? for the same gap with emails.
What people say about Claude and lead lists
| Posted | Where, when | What superagnt does |
|---|---|---|
Is anyone actually finding good leads with Claude or ChatGPT, or is it just making up companies? | r/b2bmarketing | Claude builds the list from rows the tools return, and each row carries its LinkedIn page or website. |
We use AI for both, but it never builds the list. | r/b2bmarketing, a reply in the same thread | The same split here: the tools return the rows, and Claude ranks them and writes. |
a lot of the titles are a job behind and i end up checking people by hand anyway. | r/mcp | Every person comes back with a LinkedIn profile link and an email status, so a check is one click, not a search. |
what worked, what broke, especially around verifying contacts. | r/b2bmarketing | Each email comes back marked valid, accept_all or unknown, and verify_email checks one you already have. |
Is it just hype or people are able to land meetings by this? | r/AI_Sales |
Public posts, quoted word for word and checked on Nov 18, 2026. They are what people wrote, not reviews or a survey.
A lead list Claude can't make up, step by step
- Connect superagnt (the steps for each client are above).
- Ask for the list from a search, and tell Claude not to add any company that isn't in a tool result.
- Have it pull each company's record: website, headcount, HQ. Drop what doesn't fit.
- Find the decision makers at the companies that fit, with seniority as the filter.
- Find and check emails only for the people you'll write to. What that costs, and how to cap it, is in Is there an Apollo alternative for Claude that shows the cost first?
- Let Claude rank the list and write each first line from the rows, with the source link beside each name.
Build a lead list of <ICP>. Use only companies and people that come back from your superagnt tools, and show the LinkedIn or website link for each row. If a tool returns nothing, say so; don't fill the count from memory.Common questions
01Why does Claude make up leads?
Claude has no lead database. Asked for companies from memory, it writes names that fit the pattern, with sizes and websites from old training data, and it can't check them. Connected to superagnt, it pulls real rows with their sources and only ranks and writes.
02Does turning on web search fix it?
Partly. Web search lets Claude confirm one company at a time, but it returns pages, not rows with headcount, HQ or decision makers, and only what a search engine has indexed.
03Does ChatGPT do the same?
Yes, from memory. Connected to superagnt as a custom MCP connector, ChatGPT calls the same company and people tools.
04What does a real list cost?
In the run above, ten companies with their records and eleven decision makers cost 20.7¢: 0.9¢ for the search, 17.82¢ for the records and 1.98¢ for the people.
05Where does the LinkedIn data come from?
From upstream data providers, live, with no LinkedIn login, cookie or browser extension of yours. The LinkedIn data sourcing page says more.
What else Claude can do with superagnt
- Can Claude search Twitter?
- Can Claude read Reddit threads?
- Reddit user analyzer: can Claude analyze any Reddit account?
- Can Claude look at LinkedIn profiles?
- Can Claude look at Instagram profiles?
- Can Claude watch YouTube videos?
- How do I get a YouTube transcript into Claude?
- Can Claude find email addresses?
- Can Claude verify email addresses?
- Can Claude scrape websites?
- Can Claude see my competitors' Facebook ads?
- Can Claude save data between chats?
- Can Claude load a CSV into a database?
- Can Claude run tasks on a schedule?
- Can Claude make a dashboard?
- Is there an Apollo alternative for Claude that shows the cost first?
- How do I set up signal-based prospecting with Claude?
- Why does my Reddit MCP return 403, and how do I give Claude access to Reddit now?
- How do I find buyers on Reddit with Claude?
- Which connectors should I install in Claude for marketing?
Go deeper: Lead enrichment MCP server · Company enrichment MCP server · LinkedIn data MCP server · How the LinkedIn data is sourced · AI agents for lead generation · Apollo alternative for Claude that shows the cost first · Signal-based prospecting with Claude · Can Claude find email addresses?